Supplement prices, particularly whey protein, seem to skyrocket by the day for many reasons. As an industry response to this, we have witnessed a proliferation of budget-friendly whey protein supplement options.
These may come from entirely new brands dedicated to providing cheap whey protein or as economical protein additions to existing product lines.
However, behind the appeal of these cost-effective choices often lie some concerning practices that every protein supplement users should be aware of. Not all products are created equal, after all!
In this article, I provide 5 key factors that contribute to the prevalence of inexpensive protein powders and what you should consider before making a purchase.
1-Protein as a Loss Leader
Protein, being one of the most widely consumed supplements, is often used by brands as a loss leader—a product sold at little to no profit, or even at a loss, to attract customers and establish brand loyalty.
By pricing whey protein aggressively, companies can draw in cost-conscious buyers who may then explore and purchase other higher-margin items in their lineup, such as pre-workouts, BCAAs, fat burners, or mass gainer shakes.
While this approach might seem like a win for consumers, it’s essential to understand the potential compromises behind the scenes. To keep prices low, some brands may rely on cost-cutting measures that can impact the quality, efficacy, or even the transparency of the product.
From using lower-grade raw materials to questionable manufacturing practices, these hidden trade-offs are crucial to consider when evaluating your options.
In the sections that follow, we’ll delve into these cost-cutting tactics to help you identify red flags and make more informed choices when selecting your whey protein supplement.
2: Amino Spiking: Still Around
Amino spiking, also known as protein spiking, is a sneaky tactic employed by some manufacturers to cut costs while inflating the protein content on their labels.
The practice of amino spiking was unearthed more than a decade ago and thousands of articles and rants later, this practice is still very much prevalent.
This practice involves the addition of cheaper amino acids to the protein powder. The most commonly used amino acids are Glycine and Taurine.
Now, I am not writing against these two amino acids, as they have their own benefits and applications. I use them a lot in several formulations for relaxation, sleep and overall health.
However, in the context of protein powders, they are sometimes used as spiking agents to artificially increase the protein measurement without providing the full spectrum of essential amino acids.
The Marvels of Glycine: Relaxation, Sleep, Immunity, Detoxification, and More
This deceptive practice can mislead consumers into believing they are getting more protein than they actually are.
As a consumer, it’s crucial to look beyond the flashy claims on the packaging and scrutinize the ingredient list for transparency and authenticity.
3: Added Carbs in Whey Protein Powder
Another common culprit behind the affordability of some protein powders is the addition of fillers and additives, with carbohydrate powders being a popular choice.
Now, again, let me be clear! I’m not against the strategic use of carbohydrates in protein products, especially in contexts like weight gain, meal-replacement, sports performance or post-exercise recovery.
However, in a product marketed as a “pure whey protein”, added carbs must be viewed with caution.
Whey proteins with added carbs typically come with low protein percentages (grams protein per 100g powder).
It essential to pay attention to the protein percentage and ensure that you’re not sacrificing quality for the sake of a lower price tag.
Some manufacturers may prioritise bulking up their products with fillers at the expense of protein content, compromising the overall nutritional value.
4: Misleading Branding: “WHEY” PROTEINS with added Plant Proteins
In the quest for affordability, some protein powders labeled as “whey” may contain added vegetable proteins.
While there’s nothing inherently wrong with creating a blend of whey and plant proteins, naming the product “WHEY” is highly misleading.
As a consumer, it is essential to be aware of the true composition of the product you’re purchasing and to scrutinise the ingredient list for any hidden surprises.
While vegetable proteins can offer their own nutritional benefits, it’s crucial to understand that you may not be getting the pure whey protein you expected.
4: Misleading Branding: “WHEY” PROTEINS with added Plant Proteins
In the quest for affordability, some protein powders labeled as “whey” may contain added vegetable proteins.
While there’s nothing inherently wrong with creating a blend of whey and plant proteins, naming the product “WHEY” is highly misleading.
5-Shrinkflation
An increasingly common trend in the supplement industry is the reduction of packaging sizes for protein powders. Traditionally, whey protein was sold in 2lb (908g) containers—a standard that consumers grew accustomed to. However, in recent years, some brands have begun offering smaller sizes, such as 800g or even 700g, while keeping the container dimensions nearly identical.
This practice, often referred to as “shrinkflation,” allows companies to subtly reduce the amount of product you receive without immediately drawing attention to the difference. To the untrained eye, the packaging looks the same, creating the illusion that you’re getting the same value for your money.
Additionally, brands have started prominently displaying prices for smaller-sized packages, such as 500g, in marketing and e-commerce listings. While these lower prices may seem appealing at first glance, they can mislead consumers who might not notice the reduced quantity compared to traditional 2lb tubs. In some cases, this tactic results in higher price-per-serving ratios, negating the perceived affordability.
When shopping for protein powders, it’s essential to compare not only the total price but also the net weight and cost per gram or serving. Paying close attention to these details can help ensure you’re truly getting value for your money.
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, the allure of cheap protein powders can be tempting, but it’s essential to look beyond the price tag and consider the quality, transparency, and nutritional value of the product. As a product developer, my mission is to empower consumers to make informed choices that support their health and fitness goals. By staying vigilant and educated, you can navigate the maze of protein powders with confidence and ensure that you’re investing in products that truly deliver on their promises. Remember, when it comes to your health, quality should always come before affordability.
To view my Professional Profile on LinkedIn: please click here
To see my latest product creations: www.bioteenhealth.com
To view my Scientific Publications on PubMed: please click here
To get in touch, please write to: info@supplementscientist.com
Follow supplementscientist.com on Facebook: please click here
Medical disclaimer
The information presented on this website is intended for adults 18 or over. Its aim is purely educational and does not constitute medical advice. Please consult a medical or health professional before you begin any program related to exercise, nutrition, or supplementation especially if you have a medical condition. If you consume any product mentioned on our site, you do so on your own free will, and you knowingly and voluntarily accept the risks. © 2024. Supplementscientist.com
Other: The views expressed in this blog article are solely mine and do not represent the opinions or positions of any company or institution with which I am associated. Any information or opinions provided are based on my personal experiences, research, and understanding. I strive to ensure accuracy and reliability of the information provided.
Leave a Reply